Hmmmm, I'm not sure...?

So I'm getting a new phone. I want one with good pictures, good battery life, easy texting, bright screen... I'm debating over the EnV 3, EnV Touch, or Alias 2. I wasn't too sure about getting the EnV Touch because I'm a bit clumsy and I'm afraid that if I drop it, I'll destroy the touch screen. So what do YOU think?